Nashville SC 2026/27: Comprehensive Squad Review

  • Post author:
  • Post published:
  • Post last modified:

Nashville SC enter the 2026 MLS campaign as the team to beat, and they have lived up to that billing emphatically. Under head coach B.J. Callaghan, the Boys in Gold have surged to the top of the Supporters’ Shield table with 60 points from 27 matches, boasting the league’s best defensive record and a devastating attacking trio of Hany Mukhtar, Sam Surridge, and Cristian Espinoza. With just three home matches remaining at GEODIS Park, Nashville remain the only side in North America yet to lose at home in 2026, a testament to the fortress they have built in Music City. This is the definitive guide to the current Nashville SC squad.

Nashville SC 2026/27: Comprehensive Squad Review

Technical Leadership & Coaching Profile

Manager: B.J. Callaghan

Tactical Philosophy: Callaghan has constructed one of the most balanced sides in Major League Soccer, blending a disciplined defensive structure with fluid, multi-dimensional attacking play. The midfield pivot of Matthew Corcoran and Eddi Tagseth has been central to Nashville’s dominance, combining for 19 passes into the final third and creating five chances in the recent victory over Toronto FC, while connecting on 88.2% of their long balls. The attacking structure revolves around the interplay between Mukhtar, Surridge, and Espinoza, but Callaghan has emphasised Mukhtar’s evolution into a more collective role, highlighting his work without the ball and his ability to generate space for teammates.

Preferred Formations: 4-2-3-1, with the capacity to shift based on opponent and game state. The double pivot of Corcoran and Tagseth provides the platform for the attacking quartet to operate freely.

Strategic Transfer Activity

Nashville’s roster construction has been a masterclass in balancing star power with depth and youth development. The offseason acquisition of Cristian Espinoza on a free transfer from the San Jose Earthquakes was the marquee addition, the Argentine arriving as the Earthquakes’ all-time assists leader and a two-time MLS All-Star. The summer window brought further reinforcements, with Elias Saad arriving on loan from FC Augsburg and Famara Camara joining from Ranheim IL.

Table A: Summer Major Transfer Influx

PlayerPositionFormer ClubFee Paid
Elias SaadWingerFC AugsburgLoan
Famara CamaraDefensive MidfielderRanheim ILTransfer

Elias Saad joined on loan through the 2027 MLS Sprint Season, bringing Bundesliga experience and Tunisian international pedigree. The 26-year-old started two of Tunisia’s three FIFA World Cup 26 matches and has recorded nine goals and six assists in 50 career Bundesliga 2 matches. Famara Camara, a 21-year-old Senegalese defensive midfielder, signed through June 2029 with an option through 2030. He made 40 career appearances for Ranheim IL and represented Senegal’s U20 side.

The First-Team Roster

Goalkeepers

Brian Schwake (#99): The 24-year-old has been one of the best goalkeepers in MLS in his first season as a starter, recording 59 saves and a 77.6% save percentage across 23 appearances, with 11 clean sheets. A hero of Nashville’s 2025 U.S. Open Cup triumph, Schwake has seamlessly transitioned from cup goalkeeper to league stalwart. His base salary of $150,000 represents exceptional value for a player performing at an elite level.

Joe Willis (#1): The veteran started his first match of the 2026 season against Toronto FC, making three saves to secure Nashville’s 13th shutout. Willis was a stalwart from 2019 to 2025 but took a significantly reduced salary to return as Schwake’s backup. Callaghan praised his selfless mentorship: “Whether he’s playing or he’s not playing, he trains and prepares like he’s going to be the starter.”

Xavier Valdez (#13): The Dominican goalkeeper provides third-choice depth and has been called up for international duty.

Defenders

Maxwell Woledzi (#3): The 24-year-old Ghanaian joined after winning 2025 Player of the Year honours with Fredrikstad FK. He has started 19 matches, contributing one goal, and his physicality and recovery pace have been central to Nashville’s league-best defensive record.

Jeisson Palacios (#4): The 32-year-old Colombian is a defensive cornerstone, starting 17 matches and contributing one goal. His contract extension this offseason included a significant raise to nearly $1.1 million guaranteed, reflecting his importance.

Andy Najar (#31): The 33-year-old Honduran MLS All-Star signed a contract extension that doubled his salary to $550,000. He has contributed three assists from right-back, his experience and delivery from wide areas a key outlet.

Dan Lovitz (#2): The 35-year-old veteran has started 16 matches, his consistency and tactical discipline providing stability on the left.

Jack Maher (#5): The defender earns $900,000 in base salary, the third-highest at the club, and provides reliable cover across the back line.

Reed Baker-Whiting (#27): The young defender arrived to add depth and youth, earning $275,000 in his first season.

Thomas Williams (#21): The defender provides further competition and depth.

Isaiah LeFlore (#18): The young defender joined as part of the offseason additions.

Midfielders

Hany Mukhtar (#10): The 31-year-old German is Nashville’s captain, longest-tenured player, and a club legend. His brace against Toronto FC took him to 12 league goals and made him just the 16th player in MLS history to reach 100 career goals. Beyond the numbers, Mukhtar has evolved into a leader who “talks to young guys the same way he talks to old guys,” according to Joe Willis. His base salary of $4 million makes him the ninth-highest paid player in MLS.

Cristian Espinoza (#7): The Argentine free-agent signing has been transformative, contributing four goals and eight assists in 17 starts. His 12 goal contributions make him Nashville’s most productive creator, and his ability to unlock defences from the right wing has added a new dimension to an already potent attack.

Eddi Tagseth (#20): The 25-year-old Norwegian signed a contract extension with a significant raise to $720,000 base salary. His partnership with Corcoran in the double pivot has been the engine room of Nashville’s dominance, combining defensive solidity with progressive passing.

Matthew Corcoran (#16): The 20-year-old American has emerged as a key figure, starting 14 matches and contributing two assists. His maturity and tactical intelligence belie his age, and his combination with Tagseth gives Nashville one of the most balanced midfield partnerships in the league.

Patrick Yazbek (#8): The Australian U22 Initiative player provides depth and competition in the engine room, earning $616,013 in guaranteed compensation.

Bryan Acosta (#6): The Honduran veteran provides experience and tactical discipline as a rotation option.

Alex Muyl (#19): The veteran’s deflected shot created Espinoza’s decisive goal against Inter Miami in the Concacaf Champions Cup, a moment that encapsulated his value as an impact player.

Forwards

Sam Surridge (#9): The English striker is Nashville’s highest-paid player at $5.93 million guaranteed, the seventh-highest in MLS. After scoring 31 goals across all competitions in 2025 and finishing fifth in MVP voting, Surridge has 13 goals in 14.1 90s this season, including three penalties. His 56.8% shot-on-target rate is elite.

Warren Madrigal (#41): The 21-year-old Costa Rican has been a revelation, contributing five goals and two assists in 17 starts. His brace of assists on debut against New England was the best in club history, and his development has given Callaghan genuine attacking depth.

Woobens Pacius (#17): The Haitian forward provides physical presence and competition through the middle.

Ahmed Qasem (#37): The Swedish U22 Initiative player has contributed two goals and offers pace and directness in wide areas.

Leadership Group & Squad Regulations

Club Captain: Hany Mukhtar

The German playmaker has evolved from MVP-winning scorer to the heartbeat of the club. His leadership is described by teammates as approachable and consistent, treating young and old players with equal respect. Mukhtar’s 100th career MLS goal, celebrated against Toronto, was a milestone befitting his status as one of the league’s all-time greats.

The Leadership Committee: Joe Willis, Jeisson Palacios, and Andy Najar provide veteran leadership across the squad. Willis’s selfless mentorship of Schwake, despite losing his starting role, exemplifies the culture Callaghan has cultivated.

Homegrown Quota Check: Nashville have invested in their academy pathway, with Isaiah Jones signing as a Homegrown player in 2024. Jones was loaned to Chattanooga FC for the 2026 MLS NEXT Pro season to gain regular minutes. Adem Sipić, another Homegrown signing, was loaned to Eintracht Braunschweig in Germany’s Bundesliga 2 through July 2026.

Financial & Contractual Health

Financial Balance Overview: Nashville’s total payroll is just below $20 million in base salary, ranking eighth in MLS for the second straight season. The club’s Designated Player trio of Surridge, Mukhtar, and Espinoza account for a significant portion, but the value extracted from low-cost contributors like Schwake ($150,000 base) and Madrigal ($350,000) has been remarkable.

Contract Red Alerts: Mukhtar’s contract situation will inevitably require attention given his age and continued production. The club’s ability to retain Surridge long-term will be tested if European interest materialises. The loan arrangements for Saad and the acquisition of Camara represent low-risk investments with high potential upside.

The Academy Pipeline & Loan Tracker

Breakout Talents to Watch: Adem Sipić, a Homegrown forward, was loaned to Eintracht Braunschweig to gain European experience. Isaiah Jones continues his development at Chattanooga FC in MLS NEXT Pro.

Notable Out on Loan: Isaiah Jones (Chattanooga FC), Adem Sipić (Eintracht Braunschweig). These loans are designed to provide competitive minutes and accelerate development.

Set-Piece Specialists & FPL Cheat Sheet

Penalties: Sam Surridge (First Choice). Surridge has converted three penalties this season and is the designated taker.

Direct Free-Kicks: Hany Mukhtar / Cristian Espinoza. Mukhtar’s set-piece delivery remains a weapon, while Espinoza offers an alternative from the right.

Corners & Crosses: Cristian Espinoza and Hany Mukhtar are the primary deliverers, with Andy Najar offering an alternative from right-back.

For Fantasy MLS managers, Hany Mukhtar remains a premium asset, combining goalscoring output with set-piece duties and leadership. Sam Surridge’s penalty responsibilities and 13-goal tally make him essential. Brian Schwake’s league-best 11 clean sheets and exceptional save percentage make him the standout goalkeeper option.

Final Outlook: Navigating the Tactical Horizon

Nashville SC enter the final stretch of the 2026 season as the Supporters’ Shield favourites, 10 points clear atop the table with the league’s best defensive record and a potent attacking unit. The 2-0 victory over Toronto FC, secured by Mukhtar’s brace, was their 13th clean sheet of the season and moved them to 18 wins from 27 matches.

The primary concern is squad depth in the attacking third. While Surridge, Mukhtar, and Espinoza form one of MLS’s most devastating trios, the reliance on their combined output is significant. Madrigal’s emergence has alleviated some of that pressure, and Saad’s arrival adds further firepower, but any injury to the DP trio could disrupt Nashville’s attacking rhythm.

The defensive record is the foundation of Nashville’s success. Schwake’s emergence as an elite shot-stopper, combined with the experience of Palacios and Najar and the athleticism of Woledzi, has created a back line that concedes fewer goals than any other side in the league.

Callaghan’s challenge is maintaining focus through the final stretch and the upcoming Audi MLS Cup Playoffs. The two-week break before the trip to Austin offers an opportunity to recharge before the decisive phase of the season. If Nashville maintain their defensive discipline, keep their DP trio healthy, and continue to extract value from their depth pieces, they have every chance of lifting both the Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup. The margin for error is thin, but the foundation is solid, the culture is strong, and the spirit is unbreakable.