As Nashville SC continues to establish itself as a formidable force in Major League Soccer (MLS), the 2025 squad reflects a blend of seasoned veterans, emerging talents, and strategic acquisitions. Under the guidance of their coaching staff, the team has meticulously built a roster capable of competing for titles while maintaining a strong identity rooted in defensive solidity and attacking flair. This post delves into the 2025 Nashville SC squad, breaking down each position group—goalkeepers, defenders, midfielders, and forwards—and providing an in-depth analysis of every player. From their career trajectories to their contributions on the pitch, this comprehensive highlights the depth and quality of the team.
Goalkeepers
Joe Willis
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Houston Dynamo, D.C. United
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2019
Joe Willis remains a cornerstone of Nashville SC’s defensive unit. Known for his commanding presence in the box and exceptional shot-stopping abilities, Willis has been a consistent performer since joining the club. His experience in MLS, spanning over a decade, brings invaluable leadership to the squad. In 2025, Willis continues to showcase his reflexes and ability to organize the backline, making him one of the league’s most reliable goalkeepers.
Elliot Panicco
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Charlotte Independence (USL)
Transfer Fee: Signed as a free agent in 2020
Elliot Panicco has developed into a dependable backup option for Nashville SC. Standing at 6’5”, his height gives him an edge in aerial duels, while his distribution skills have improved significantly. Panicco’s performances in cup competitions and during Willis’ occasional absences have demonstrated his readiness to step up when called upon. His potential to grow into a starting role makes him a valuable asset for the future.
Ben Martino
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Philadelphia Union II (MLS Next Pro)
Transfer Fee: Undisclosed (Homegrown signing)
A promising young goalkeeper, Ben Martino joined Nashville SC as part of their commitment to nurturing homegrown talent. At just 22 years old, Martino has already shown glimpses of his potential during preseason and training sessions. His agility and quick reflexes make him a standout prospect, and the club is carefully managing his development to ensure he reaches his full potential.
Defenders
Walker Zimmerman
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: LAFC, FC Dallas
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2020
Walker Zimmerman is the heart and soul of Nashville SC’s defense. A two-time MLS Defender of the Year, Zimmerman combines physicality, intelligence, and leadership to anchor the backline. His ability to read the game and make crucial interventions has made him a fan favorite and a key figure for the U.S. Men’s National Team. In 2025, Zimmerman remains a dominant force, consistently shutting down opposing attackers and contributing to set-piece goals.
Jack Maher
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Indiana University (NCAA)
Transfer Fee: Selected in the 2020 MLS SuperDraft
Jack Maher has blossomed into a reliable center-back partner for Zimmerman. His composure on the ball and ability to play out from the back align perfectly with Nashville’s tactical approach. Maher’s aerial prowess and tackling accuracy have earned him a regular starting role, and at 25, he is poised to become one of the league’s top defenders.
Shaq Moore
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Tenerife (Spain), Levante (Spain)
Transfer Fee: $2 million (2022)
Shaq Moore brings international experience and versatility to Nashville’s defense. Capable of playing as a right-back or wing-back, Moore’s pace and defensive awareness make him a constant threat on both ends of the pitch. His contributions in the 2025 season have been pivotal, with his overlapping runs and crosses adding a new dimension to the team’s attack.
Daniel Lovitz
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Montreal Impact, D.C. United
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2020
Daniel Lovitz continues to be a steady presence at left-back. Known for his work rate and crossing ability, Lovitz provides width and defensive stability. His experience and consistency have made him a trusted figure in the squad, and his leadership qualities are evident both on and off the pitch.
Lukas MacNaughton
Nationality: Canadian
Former Clubs: Toronto FC
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2023
Lukas MacNaughton has proven to be a shrewd acquisition for Nashville SC. His versatility allows him to play as a center-back or right-back, providing depth and flexibility to the defense. MacNaughton’s physicality and tactical awareness have made him a valuable asset, particularly in high-stakes matches.
Taylor Washington
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL)
Transfer Fee: Signed as a free agent in 2020
Taylor Washington’s energy and determination make him a valuable squad player. Primarily used as a backup left-back, Washington’s ability to contribute defensively and offensively has earned him the respect of teammates and fans alike. His commitment to the club’s ethos is unwavering.
Midfielders
Dax McCarty
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: Chicago Fire, New York Red Bulls
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2020
Dax McCarty remains a vital cog in Nashville’s midfield. His vision, passing range, and ability to control the tempo of the game are unmatched. Despite being in the latter stages of his career, McCarty’s leadership and experience continue to inspire the team. His mentorship of younger players has been instrumental in their development.
Aníbal Godoy
Nationality: Panamanian
Former Clubs: San Jose Earthquakes
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2020
Aníbal Godoy’s tenacity and defensive acumen make him a key figure in Nashville’s midfield. His ability to break up play and distribute the ball effectively has been crucial to the team’s success. Godoy’s international experience with Panama adds another layer of depth to his game.
Hany Mukhtar
Nationality: German
Former Clubs: Brøndby (Denmark), Benfica (Portugal)
Transfer Fee: $2.8 million (2020)
Hany Mukhtar is the creative engine of Nashville SC. The 2022 MLS MVP continues to dazzle with his dribbling, vision, and goal-scoring prowess. In 2025, Mukhtar remains the team’s talisman, consistently delivering match-winning performances. His ability to unlock defenses and create chances makes him one of the league’s most feared attackers.
Randall Leal
Nationality: Costa Rican
Former Clubs: Saprissa (Costa Rica)
Transfer Fee: $1.5 million (2020)
Randall Leal’s versatility and technical skills make him a valuable asset in midfield. Whether deployed as a winger or central midfielder, Leal’s pace and creativity pose constant problems for opponents. His work ethic and commitment to the team’s cause are commendable.
Sean Davis
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: New York Red Bulls
Transfer Fee: Signed as a free agent in 2022
Sean Davis has seamlessly integrated into Nashville’s midfield. His ability to dictate play and contribute defensively has made him a key player. Davis’ leadership qualities and consistency have earned him a regular starting role, and his experience in MLS is invaluable.
Brian Anunga
Nationality: Cameroonian
Former Clubs: Charleston Battery (USL)
Transfer Fee: Signed as a free agent in 2020
Brian Anunga’s physicality and energy make him a valuable squad player. Primarily used as a defensive midfielder, Anunga’s ability to disrupt opposition play and protect the backline has been crucial. His contributions off the bench often provide a spark for the team.
Forwards
Sam Surridge
Nationality: English
Former Clubs: Nottingham Forest (England), Stoke City (England)
Transfer Fee: $4 million (2024)
Sam Surridge’s arrival in 2024 added a new dimension to Nashville’s attack. The towering striker’s aerial ability and clinical finishing have made him a fan favorite. In 2025, Surridge continues to lead the line with poise, consistently finding the back of the net and creating opportunities for his teammates.
Teal Bunbury
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: New England Revolution, Sporting Kansas City
Transfer Fee: Signed as a free agent in 2023
Teal Bunbury’s experience and versatility make him a valuable asset in the forward line. Whether playing as a striker or winger, Bunbury’s work rate and ability to hold up play have been crucial. His leadership and professionalism set a high standard for younger players.
Ethan Zubak
Nationality: American
Former Clubs: LA Galaxy
Transfer Fee: Signed as a free agent in 2023
Ethan Zubak’s physical presence and goal-scoring instincts make him a reliable option off the bench. His ability to make an impact in limited minutes has been a valuable asset for Nashville SC. Zubak’s dedication to improving his game is evident in his performances.
Handwalla Bwana
Nationality: Somali
Former Clubs: Seattle Sounders, Nashville SC (loan)
Transfer Fee: Acquired via trade in 2022
Handwalla Bwana’s flair and creativity make him a dynamic option in the forward line. His ability to take on defenders and create chances has added depth to Nashville’s attack. Bwana’s versatility allows him to play multiple roles, making him a valuable squad player.
Conclusion
The 2025 Nashville SC squad is a testament to the club’s strategic planning and commitment to excellence. With a blend of experienced leaders, emerging talents, and impactful signings, the team is well-equipped to compete at the highest level. Each player brings unique qualities that contribute to the collective success of the squad, making Nashville SC a force to be reckoned with in MLS. As the season unfolds, fans can look forward to thrilling performances and a team that embodies the spirit of Music City.
